What If I

"What If I" is a song by That Poppy.

Background
What If I was written and recorded in 2012 during Poppy's experimental phase.

In 2014, Poppy handed the project over to Brett Manning, who recorded for it.

Theme
"What If I" is about questioning a lover. The person describes ways they could have altered situations so their relationship wouldn't have existed. However, since they didn't do this in the past, they won't in the present. Their lover is described to have positively impacted them, but they wonder how things would have been different if they met their partner on another day.